In a tweet on May 25, Arkansas Lieutenant Governor and former Arkansas Attorney General Leslie Rutledge voiced her support for a recent Supreme Court ruling in the case of Sackett v. Environmental Protection Agency.
In a 9-0 decision, the Court overturned a lower court’s ruling against Chantell and Mike Sackett, an Idaho couple who have been at odds with the EPA since 2007. The Sacketts were attempting to build a house on an empty lot that sits about 300 feet from Idaho’s Priest Lake. After the couple began backfilling the property to prepare for construction, they received notice from the EPA that the lot contained wetlands protected under the Clean Water Act of 1972.
Per the agency’s reasoning, the wetlands on the Sacketts’ property fed into a non-navigable creek leading into Priest Lake, which is bordered by both state and national parkland. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit, applying a test outlined in an earlier case by Justice Anthony Kennedy, agreed that the couple’s lot was a wetland as protected under the CWA.
The CWA prohibits the discharge of pollutants, including rocks and sand, into “navigable waters.” The definition of “navigable waters,” and what areas should be protected under the act, was the main source of contention between both parties in the case and even among the justices.
All nine justices agreed that the Sacketts’ lot specifically should not have come under the purview of the CWA. However, four justices disagreed with the new test put forward in Justice Samuel Alito’s opinion on the case. Under that more stringent test, the CWA would extend only to streams, oceans, rivers and lakes, as well as wetlands with a “continuous surface connection” to a larger body of water.
In an opinion joined by liberal Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan and Ketanji Brown Jackson, conservative Justice Brett Kavanaugh took issue with the narrow scope of Alito’s reasoning. Kavanaugh raised concerns that the new interpretation of the CWA now excludes a number of previously-regulated wetlands, which could have “significant repercussions for water quality and flood control throughout the United States.”
Kavanaugh also used the Mississippi River as an example, pointing out that wetlands on the other side of levees on the river will no longer be covered by the CWA under the new test, despite being “an important part of the flood-control project” for the river.
In her tweet, Rutledge called the ruling a “HUGE win for Arkansas’s farmers & landowners at the Supreme Court” and attributed the “overreaching EPA rules” to the Obama and Biden administrations.
As Kavanaugh noted in his opinion, eight consecutive presidential administrations, both Democrat and Republican, have interpreted the law to cover wetlands that will no longer be included per the new test.
In a separate opinion joined by the other liberal justices, Kagan also criticized the Court’s “appointment of itself as the national decision-maker on environmental policy,” alleging that the majority is undermining attempts from Congress to address pollution.
In a statement released after the ruling, EPA Administrator Michael S. Regan expressed his disappointment that the Court’s decision “erodes longstanding clean water protections.”
“In 1972, an overwhelming bipartisan majority in Congress passed the Clean Water Act, giving EPA and Army Corp implementation responsibilities. In doing so, our leaders recognized that protecting our nation’s waters is vital to ensuring a thriving economy and agricultural sector, to sustaining diverse ecosystems and to protecting the water our children drink,” Regan said.
“Over the past 50 years, we have made transformational progress — rivers that were once on fire have been restored and now sustain vibrant communities in every corner of the country. A common sense and science-based definition of ‘waters of the United States’ is essential to building on that progress and fulfilling our responsibility to preserve our nation’s waters — now and for future generations.”
READ ALSO: JUNIOR ACHIEVEMENT OF ARKANSAS HOLDS 2023 LEGACY LUNCHEON
