Feature image above: Jacksonville Mayor Jeff Elmore, right, with his wife, Michelle, and sons Wyatte, left, 19, and Carter, 17
When Jacksonville Mayor Jeff Elmore and his family purchased the former Keith & Co. Artisan Sandwich Shop, it was not something they had planned for. However, the venture has provided Elmore with the ideal way to practice what he preaches when it comes to community investment.
“Us keeping the restaurant here was just one more little part of the quality of life that we’re offering for people that are here,” he said. “There’s a lot going on.”
Keith & Co. had been a staple in the city. When the restaurant that took its place shut down after just a few months, it came as a surprise to Elmore, who visited the owner to say goodbye.

Photo by DeWaine Duncan
During that discussion, the owner asked if Elmore wanted to buy the restaurant. He went home and talked it over with his wife, Michelle, and sons Wyatt, 19, and Carter, 17. The family was on board.
“I literally woke up that morning with owning a restaurant not even on the bingo card, and we went to bed that night with basically a hand-shake agreement that we were going to own a restaurant,” Elmore said.
That is not to say that the family had never discussed buying a restaurant before; it had just been more of an idle dream than an actual plan.
Elmore, who has a background in ministry and owns a title company in Jacksonville, entered the competitive barbecue circuit with a friend about 20 years ago while living in Georgia but stopped competing after moving to Arkansas. Although his smoked briskets and pork butts were in demand for parties and church functions, Elmore never worked as a professional caterer, and he had no restaurant experience prior to opening Four Elms Bistro in May.
“The hardest thing with opening the restaurant was figuring out a name,” he said. “It was three days we were wrestling, fighting at the house. ‘What’s it going to be?’ ‘No, I don’t like that.’ ‘No, I don’t like that.’ Three would like it, and one wouldn’t or whatever, and just it was hard. I mean, it really was. We picked names for our children easier than we picked names for the restaurant.”

Photo by DeWaine Duncan
Then, finally, Michelle came up with a name all four Elmores could get behind: Four Elms Bistro. A play on the family’s name and number, the moniker also provided an easy branding opportunity in incorporating an elm tree into the logo.
Elmore credited the bistro’s success so far to longstanding employees who worked at the previous restaurants. For the most part, the menu is the same as the one offered at Keith & Co. with a few additions.
“We’ve added some and tried to make it our own but kind of brought back all the favorites that everybody missed, and the response has been just unreal, more gratitude than anything,” he said. “They’re like, ‘Thank you for giving us this spot and having this type of restaurant in town because we don’t have anything like this.’ It’s unique.”
The bistro is open for breakfast and lunch on weekdays, and Elmore said he would eventually like to open on the weekends, as well. The chicken bacon ranch and club sandwiches are the most popular lunch items, along with the pimento and bacon sandwich; the nachos, which are made with wontons instead of tortillas; and a peanut butter and jelly sandwich with bacon.
“People are like, ‘Really?’ and then they’ll try it, and they’re like, ‘Holy cow, where has this been all my life?’” Elmore said. “We’ve got a couple customers that come in here, and that’s all they ever get. They’re getting a PB&J and bacon, so it’s kind of unique. I like it. I’m not going to order it with my meal, but to me, it’s like, man, it’s the perfect late-night [snack].”
Breakfast options include an omelet of the day, the chorizo hashbrown bowl, and the “knife and a fork” chicken biscuit, which is a biscuit with fried chicken and a fried egg topped with sausage gravy. There is also the off-the-menu “mayor’s special,” which Elmore popularized prior to buying the restaurant: a bowl of cheese grits topped with chorizo.
Elmore said he is still learning the rhythm of the restaurant industry. When business slowed in July, he said he was concerned at first but heard from other restaurant owners that it is normal to experience a lull as customers go out of town on vacation. Sure enough, business picked back up in August, and now he is eager to see what changes the holiday season might bring.

Photo by DeWaine Duncan
Although Elmore is not involved in the day-to-day operations of the business, Wyatt, who is studying at Ouachita Baptist University in Arkadelphia, had a chance to work at the restaurant this summer.
“It’s cool to have something of our own that we’re getting to do and a new family project, pretty much, that we really hadn’t planned on doing until right when we opened it,” Wyatt said. “We knew about a week ahead of time that we were doing it, and then all of a sudden, we owned a restaurant, but I mean, it’s really fun getting to do all this with all them and figuring it out as we go.”
Elmore said unlike the title company, where his wife is now president, his sons get to have a say in the running of the restaurant.
“The boys weren’t involved in that. You know, she’d come home, or I’d come home, and we’d talk about it. They were like, ‘Please, can y’all stop talking business? We’re home now,’” he said. “This is something that we can all talk about, and so I guess in that regard, it’s been good in bringing us together because it is something in common that we all four have and can share and feel that personal ownership with.”
Although he said he might consider franchising the restaurant in the future, which he believes is the only way the family could actually profit from the venture, the point of buying the restaurant was not to make money; it was to support the community.
“We opened it to keep the restaurant here and to provide quality of life for the city and to keep the employees who were here employed,” he said. “I’m not making a dime on this place. It’s paying for itself, which is all that I ask, you know?”
With revitalization in progress in all areas of the city, international companies such as Sig Sauer bringing jobs to town, a thriving new school district and new housing developments underway, the future looks bright for Jacksonville.
Elmore said he hopes his family’s investment shows the value of small businesses.
“I’m looking at it through multiple lenses, and I see what it does for the city in keeping this here, so it was one of those things — ‘OK, I’m the mayor, but I’m going to lead by example, and I’m going to put my money where my mouth is,’” he said. “I want people to come invest in our town. If I’m not willing to do it myself, why should I ask someone else to? So we did.”
Four Elms Bistro
9 Crestview Drive, Jacksonville
501-596-9700
Open 7 a.m. to 2 p.m. Monday-Friday
READ ALSO: Christina Muñoz Joins Wildwood Park for the Arts Leadership Team
