Cellphones and other personal electronic devices will soon be out of the hands of Arkansas students thanks to the Bell to Bell, No Cell Act, which requires public school districts and open-enrollment public charter schools to create policies prohibiting the possession of such devices on campus while school is in session.
The issue had been on the minds of Arkansas lawmakers since at least last year, when Gov. Sarah Huckabee Sanders sent a copy of The Anxious Generation by Jonathan Haidt to every member of the Arkansas legislature, along with governors across the U.S. The book details the damaging effects of youth cellphone and social media use.
Sen. Tyler Dees (R-Siloam Springs), lead sponsor, told the 95th General Assembly the purpose of the bill was twofold: to eliminate distractions in the classroom and to improve youth socialization. He cited data from The Anxious Generation and the Manhattan Institute showing teenage social media use causes sleep deprivation, mental health issues and academic problems.
“The stats that we’re starting to see across the country with rise in anxiety and depression and suicidal thoughts are all being stemmed back to upstream issues related to addiction to screens, to cellphone use, to social media exposure, and, unfortunately, that’s happening all the time in our schools, and we can’t stand for that,” he said. “We can’t continue to harbor that and encourage that in our school system.”
Rep. Zack Gramlich (R-Fort Smith), a teacher at Darby Middle School in Fort Smith, spoke in favor of the bill, telling the House it is difficult for educators to compete with smart devices for students’ attention.

Rep. Zack Gramlich
“The amount of behavior issues we have because of cellphones in our school is untold, and I can’t put a number to how much many, many teachers in this state are excited for a bill like this,” he said. “We want the phones out of our classrooms. We want to be able to teach again.”
He detailed some of the effects of cellphone use among his students to Arkansas Money & Politics.
“I see, in my class daily, cellphones,” he said. “We have tried to do a pretty good job in my school of saying no phones in class, but what ends up happening is because phones are allowed in the hallways, allowed at lunch, kids will sneak them, and they will hide them in their pockets and stuff like that. What ends up happening is they just stay distracted on them most of the day, and that’s really at the best level.”
At the worst level, he said, students text each other to organize fights in the bathrooms, which they film to post on social media, or use the photo and video capabilities of the devices to bully other students.
Gramlich has also noticed cellphone usage taking the place of face-to-face interactions among teens. He estimated about 75 percent of students at his school spend lunchtime on their phones.
“They are playing games, watching videos. They are not socializing or communicating with the other people around them,” he said. “That sense of isolation that comes with that will not support them in their growth and development in the future.”
Even his students seem to understand the benefits of having their phones out of reach at school, he added.
“I’ve got a lot of kids who have voluntarily been like, ‘Hey, Mr. Gramlich, I’m going to leave my cellphone with you for the day. I just, like, it’s a lot right now,’” he said. “I’m like, ‘Yeah, sure. OK, let’s put it in a desk and then come back after school.’ [Then] I’m like, ‘Hey, I’ve got to ask — was your day better because of it?’ They’re like, ‘Yeah, no, it was a lot better. I got a lot of stuff done. You know, I felt like I wasn’t distracted all day.’
“Kids know. It’s just these little things are little dopamine pumps, and it’s really, really hard to set something down that makes you feel good.”
While two middle schools in the Fort Smith Public School District participated in a statewide pilot program for cellphone-free schools launched last summer, his was not one of them, he said, adding that the disparity caused confusion among students, some of whom brought the Yondr pouches used to stow phones for the pilot program to Darby Middle School when they transferred schools.
“When we have inconsistent rules on our cellphones, weird things happen,” he said. “If districts are consistent on, ‘This is the cellphone rule wherever you go,’ whether it’s a pack or whether it’s in your bag, then kids will know how to react.”
The Bell to Bell, No Cell Act ensures consistency, he said, and it keeps 13-year-old students from worrying that at any point, someone could take a picture or video of them doing something embarrassing at school.
“When we look at schools that have voluntarily gone bell-to-bell, no cellphones, we see lower risks, lower instances of behavior [problems]. We see higher test scores,” he said. “I would hope that we begin to see those trends continuing into the future for all districts across our state.”
While the law only applies to public schools and open-enrollment public charter schools, Dees pointed out during his remarks to the Senate that many private schools in Arkansas already had such rules in place. Catholic High School for Boys in Little Rock was one such school.
“Catholic High has always had a bell-to-bell policy, and the results of that have been rewarding to say the least,” said Steve Straessle, head of school. “In the past, boys have reported that they feel like our policy gives them a break from their phones and that it is worthwhile to not have that distraction in the classroom.”

Steve Straessle
Since about 2004, when cellphones started becoming a ubiquitous part of teenage day gear, the school has required students to have their phones turned off and stored in their lockers during the school day. However, the school has considered changing the policy in the past.
“About 2014, 10 years later, there was a real push in education to allow students to have cellphones in the classroom, and the logic was that they are supercomputers in their pockets, and they use them out of school for everything else,” Straessle said. “I can remember being at a conference and having the presenters say, ‘You know, when you are discussing Napoleon, your students can have their phones out and be looking up who Napoleon was and the battles he fought and so forth,’ and I remember walking away from there thinking, ‘Do we really think they’ll be looking up Napoleon instead of other things?’”
Now, he said, Haidt’s book, coupled with other data about youth cellphone use and its impact, has validated the school’s decision.
“In a nutshell, Jonathan Haidt pointed out that kids today are sleep deprived, that they’re staying up late on their phones,” Straessle said. “They are socially deprived. That means that they may have a number of quote-unquote ‘friends’ in social media, but the quality of their friendships is lacking. They suffer from addiction, and that’s to pornography and games and the like button in terms of phones, and then they suffer from attention fragmentation in that such easy access to social media has forced their attention span to last mere seconds as opposed to training long attention spans necessary for being successful in adult lives.
“Those four takeaways, you pull those together, and that is the youth mental health crisis.”
Catholic High recently challenged its students to delete two social media apps for Lent, a 40-day period of penance leading up to Easter. Straessle said he was surprised by how many students participated in the voluntary challenge.
“The very next day, the number of kids who were saying without prompt, ‘I feel better,’ or ‘I slept better,’ was impressive,” he said. “The other side of that was the number that reported that they would reflexively go to their phones and hit the spot on their screen where the now-deleted social media icon was, was disturbing.”
It is no accident that kids tap the apps without even realizing it. Ravi Iyer, managing director at the Neely Center for Ethical Leadership and Decision Making at the University of Southern California Marshall School of Business, who worked at Facebook as product manager, data scientist and research manager from 2018 to 2022, said social media companies use powerful artificial intelligence systems and harness the “fast” system of the brain, also known as System 1, to ensure users engage with their products as much as possible.

Ravi Iver
“There’s, a lot of times, a complex relationship with our devices where we actually would like to put them down, but they’re full of apps that are trying to get us to use them more,” he said. “Especially for kids, who are still developing their inhibition systems, the brains are not fully developed in terms of stopping themselves from doing things, you know. We need to give them some help.”
He worked with Haidt on Chapter 10 of The Anxious Generation, which provides recommendations for governments, including policies such as the Bell to Bell, No Cell Act that prohibit cellphone possession during the schoolday.
With social media impacting students’ sleep, reducing their attention spans and causing safety concerns at schools, in addition to causing morale and retention problems among teachers when cellphones make their way into the classroom, it is important to pass strong legislation now, while lawmakers are paying attention, he said.
“There’s nothing more important than our kids’ mental health, our kids’ ability to pay attention, our kids’ ability to form social relationships,” he said, “and so this is 100 percent a critical issue.”
Such laws are gaining traction not just in Arkansas but across the United States and around the world. Iyer said it is difficult to find a state where cellphone-free schools are not being considered.
“It is not a red state issue or a blue state issue or a purple state issue,” he said. “Every state is wrestling with these issues. Every state is seeing teachers complain about the distractions. Every state where they are actually going phone free earnestly is reporting positive effects.”
He added that he would also like to see enforced age restrictions for social media and the minimum age to open a social media account set higher than 13, the age at which websites can currently collect information from children without parental permission.
Australia recently passed a law preventing people younger than 16 from using social media apps, which Iyer said he hopes could be a model for the U.S. and other parts of the world.
Other potential legislation includes data interoperability requirements such as those recently passed in Utah that allow users to switch platforms while retaining profile content and digital taxes such as those proposed in Maryland that could help fund youth mental health care.
If bell-to-bell policies and other measures are not passed to curb youth social media use, Iyer said, the consequences could be dire.
“We’d have a generation of kids who have difficulty relating to people in everyday life and who have mental health issues and attention issues, and I think just spiritually, we’ll lose something when everyone is interacting in electronic mediums and not face to face,” he said. “We evolved for millions of years as a species that interacted in face-to-face interactions, so there’s a one-dimensionality of online life where it’s easier to fight with people or it’s easier to be seduced by people.”
READ ALSO: Pickleball Kingdom to Open First Arkansas Location in Little Rock
