The shifting economy for newspapers trying to make the transition from a print-dominant world to a digitally-dominated world continues. And some counties and towns are finding themselves in a news desert as their papers shut down, and the nearest television station is more than an hour away.
That was certainly the case in 2018 for Arkadelphia and Stuttgart in 2019.
But not every town is in the same boat. For Eureka Springs, a town with a population of just over 2,000, two newspapers work to bring headlines to their readers every week.
One of those newspapers is the Eureka Springs Independent, and the other is the Lovely County Citizen. Both papers are published on Wednesdays.
The Lovely County Citizen gets its name from Lovely County, which officially existed in this Arkansas territory from Oct. 13, 1827 to Oct. 17, 1828. The county encompassed what is now Northwest Arkansas and a chunk of northeast Oklahoma, the newspaper’s website states.
It is published by Rust Publishing (which also publishes the Carroll County News) and is the older of the two newspapers. The Eureka Springs Independent published its first issue on July 5, 2012.
Samantha Jones is associate editor for Carroll County Newspapers and oversees the day-to-day news coverage for the Citizen. She notes that Eureka Springs is a small town bringing in thousands of tourists each year. This leaves the local government to make big decisions while still maintaining a small-town atmosphere.
“City council meetings often include more than 30 minutes of citizen comments, sometimes much more. That level of involvement isn’t something you see in many towns of our size,” Jones says. “People in Eureka Springs want to talk about the issues that affect both citizens and tourists. It’s a fascinating place to practice journalism for sure.”
Mary Pat Boian is editor of the Eureka Springs Independent. She says Eureka Springs never has a news shortage. Her newspaper covers the city council, quorum court, airport commission, school board, Holiday Island government and more.
The most popular stories in the Citizen often have to do with covering local government, according to Jones.
“When I started this job, I heard people call city council meetings ‘entertainment.’ The citizens are watching what council members do, and they want to read about it,” she says.
Other popular topics in the Citizen include school news and the Citizen of the Week feature, Jones says.
The two editors had different takes on why the small town was able to support two newspapers.
Boian says Eureka Springs has had competing newspapers since 1880, sometimes two dailies.
“They merge, go belly up, stay in business for years and then shut down, but newspapers have been primarily politically neutral, staying in business because they make people feel in touch with what’s going on.”
She adds while most have their five favorite websites they check every hour, that list is different for everyone. But a newspaper is something they can all read and discuss over coffee.
“They might interpret things differently, but they’re talking about the same thing. There is another paper distributed in Eureka Springs, but it’s really out of Berryville,” she says.
Jones says local politics and personalities can cause a big divide, even in a smaller town like Eureka Springs.
“We certainly have a bit of that going on in Eureka Springs,” she says.
The Eureka Springs Independent distributes 2,500 papers to newspaper boxes, racks and countertops in downtown Eureka Springs and along U.S. Highway 62, according to Boian. Another 1,500 are divided among Berryville, Holiday Island and Highway 86 in nearby Barry County, Mo.
“We also have paid subscriptions throughout the country,” Boian says.
Scott Loftis is managing editor for Carroll County Newspapers and oversees day-to-day news for the Carroll County News.
“We print 4,000 copies of the Citizen each week. Since it’s a free publication, there are very few folks who pay for an actual subscription,” Loftis says.
He adds the Citizen’s circulation is audited, and it’s the only paper in Eureka Springs with both an audited circulation and a membership to the Arkansas Press Association.
While other newspaper editors are working to keep their publications going strong, Boian says there’s a secret to keeping a publication going in 2020.
“People like to read about themselves and their friends without all the misfortunes and misinformation they get on Facebook.”
Jones says the secret to keeping a newspaper going in this environment is listening to people.
“Take phone calls from supporters and critics, and treat them the same,” she says. “Don’t be afraid to report the facts. Citizens respect a newspaper that represents their interests, and our coverage certainly does that.”
As for what the future looks like for the Citizen, Jones says, “The future looks a lot like what we are doing now: covering the news, stating the facts and sharing the good in our community. It’s all about striking that balance just right and continuing to move forward.”
READ MORE: Virus or Not, Holidays Persist
